Fact Checked by Editorial Staff 
In general, a Limited Liability Company (LLC) in New York does not pay any taxes like corporations and other business structures. It has a pass-through taxation instead of business or corporate tax. Besides, the LLC tax structure includes state and federal mandatory taxes. LLCs are required to choose the tax structure at the time of filing the company.
IRS (Internal Revenue Service) allows an LLC in New York to choose its preferred classification of tax at the beginning of the LLC filing. For example, a single-member LLC is taxed as a sole proprietor, and a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership. As there is no fixed tax structure for LLCs, everyone certainly wants to opt for the most beneficial one. On this page, LLCBuddy editors shared all about the tax structure in New York LLC.
How Does Taxation Work in a New York LLC
For an LLC in New York, the tax structure is very simple and flexible. First of all, every LLC has the advantage of a pass-through taxation. On the other hand, an LLC can choose the desired tax structure at the time of formation. There are two ways an LLC can be taxed,
As a Sole Proprietorship
A single-member LLC is usually considered a sole proprietorship company. Hence, by default, it is taxed as a sole proprietorship. A single-member LLC is also called a disregarded entity. Under the U.S. tax law, it is assumed that a single-member LLC is owned by an individual (& not by another LLC), so the U.S. tax law levies rules on it as a Sole Proprietor. A single-member LLC’s owner (Sole Proprietor) has to report all the income of the LLC via their own income tax return.
As mentioned earlier, the single owner of the LLC is treated as the Sole proprietor of the LLC & has to file the Self-Employment Tax on all of the LLC’s earnings. New York does not levy State Income Tax, so a single-member LLC must file only the Federal Income Tax.
As a Partnership
Any LLC with more than one owner is referred to as a Multi-Member LLC & it is taxed as a partnership by default. Similar to the Single Owner or Single Member LLC, this LLC is also a pass-through entity. This means that the income of the LLC passes through the income of the members & they have to file taxes through their own earnings.
Partnership or Multi-Member LLC has to pay taxes similar to those of the Single-Member LLC. If the Partnership LLC is directly owned by individuals, it is exempt from the Franchise Tax. All the members of the Multi-Member LLC are liable to pay Self-Employment Tax & Federal Income Tax.
Pass-through Taxation for New York LLC
A Limited Liability Company (LLC) is a form of business structure that consists of members and/or managers (owners). The biggest advantage of an LLC in New York is the pass-through taxation. The limited liability company does not pay any federal income taxes based on the revenue of the company. Instead, the tax liability passes through to each member of the LLC. Furthermore, the members will have to pay individual income tax based on their income.
Both for a single-member LLC and a multi-member LLC in New York, the tax burden passes through to the member(s). In other cases, if an LLC chooses to be taxed as a Corporation, the LLC will have to pay federal income tax based on its revenue and profit. There is no pass-through taxation for C-Corp and S-Corp.
Options to Change Default Tax Classification
The LLCs are categorized either as sole proprietorships or as partnerships, depending on the number of members the LLC has. This is the default tax classification applicable to LLCs. However, the LLCs have an option of changing the default classification & opting to register under the following categories for taxation purposes:
C-Corporation
An LLC can prefer to be treated as a C-corporation by filing Form 8832 (the Entity Classification Election Form) with the IRS. The C-corporation is a regular corporation that is subject to corporate taxes & it is not a pass-through entity.
An LLC taxed as a C-Corporation is not a pass-through entity. In a C-corporation, the members/shareholders/ owners are taxed separately. The shareholders of the C-corporation are taxed twice on the dividends that they earn. The dividends of the shareholders are taxed at the corporate level, with a Corporate Tax filed with Form 1120 & at a Shareholder level, an Income Tax filed with Form 1040. Shareholders are subject to Federal Income Tax.
S-Corporation
The S-Corporation is the most common type of corporate structure used by small businesses. It was created to provide corporations with limited liability protection while maintaining the benefits of being a separate legal entity. An LLC can prefer to be treated as an S-Corporation by filing Form 2553. S corporations are small business corporations that choose to pass through the corporate income, losses, deductions, & credits to the shareholders for the purposes of Federal Taxes.
An S-Corporation is similar to an LLC except that it is treated by the IRS as a corporation for tax purposes. S-Corps do pay corporate income taxes; however, they are still considered disregarded entities for federal tax purposes.
Like an LLC, an S-Corp reports its annual earnings on a separate Schedule E on the member’s personal account. An S-Corp is treated by the IRS much like a partnership for tax purposes. Unlike Partnership, in S Corporation, the shareholders are required to pay Federal Self Income tax on their share of the company’s profits.
LLC Taxes to be Paid in New York
One of the biggest tax advantages of an LLC is the ability to avoid double taxation. The IRS (Internal Revenue Service) considers LLC as a “pass-through entity” hence all the taxes are to be paid by the members of the LLC to the state as well as to the Federal Government. An LLC in the state of New York has to pay two types of taxes to the New York Department of Taxation and Finance:
State Income Tax
As an LLC owner in New York, you pay yourself through the earnings. These earnings get reflected in your personal Tax return & are calculated at the time of paying the Income Tax.
The Standard New York State Tax rate ranges between 4% and 8.82%, depending on your earnings. The state tax rate varies based on multiple factors such as the place you live, your adjusted gross income, and your taxable income amount. You may also get the opportunity to claim all the standard allowances & deductions upon filing the tax return.
Sales and Use Tax
The State Sales and Use tax rate in New York is 4%. Tax-exempted goods are food, medications, clothing, and gas. Other local taxing jurisdictions, such as cities and counties, may impose an additional sales tax.
Corporate Franchise Tax
New York levies a tax on certain businesses for the right to exist as a legal entity and do certain business in the state. LLCs are exempt from paying the corporate business tax unless they file their taxes as corporations.
Federal Self-Employment Tax
Anyone earning profit from the LLC must pay the self-employment tax. The Federal Self-Employment Tax applies to all the earnings of an LLC member or manager. The tax covers security, Medicare, and other benefits. The Federal Self-Employment Tax rate in New York is 15.3%. To deduct your LLC’s expenses from the income earned, you must calculate the Self-Employment Tax your LLC owes.
Federal Income Tax
Nearly all working Americans are required to file a tax return with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) every year. Like State Income Tax, this tax also applies to the earnings you make in your LLC.
The Federal Income Tax Rate is subject to the earnings you make, the type of your LLC’s industry, the current income tax bracket that is applicable, deductions applicable, and your filing status. One only pays Federal income tax on profits you take out of the business, allowances, and certain deductions.
Employee & Employer Taxes
The Employee & employer tax implications are different from all the other types mentioned above. All the employees of an LLC have to collect and withhold the Payroll tax at the time of receiving the salary. Each employee has to mandatorily file an individual tax return, irrespective of whether they withhold the Federal Tax or not.
Classification of New York LLC Taxes
An LLC is considered a Pass-through Entity because it allows the income to pass through & become self-employment income. The members of the LLC have to pay Self-employment tax or Self-Employment Taxes on any income they earn through the LLC. The LLC has to pay Franchise Tax on its income. In addition to the Self-employment tax, there are some other requirements that an LLC has to consider, such as:
- Franchise Tax – Franchise tax applies to or levies upon LLCs, C-corporations, & S-corporations. Sole Proprietorship & Partnerships (directly owned by individuals) are exempted from the Franchise Tax. This tax is to be paid to the office of the Comptroller of Public Accounts.
- Federal Tax Identification Number – An LLC with employees must obtain a Federal Tax Identification Number. New York does not have a separate State Tax Identification number.
- State Employer Taxes – If an LLC has employees on the payroll, it must pay state employer taxes in New York. These taxes are handled through the New York Workforce Commission.
- Franchise Tax Report – In New York, the LLCs file a Franchise Tax Report. This report has to be submitted to New York State.
Federal Tax Classifications
When LLCs were recognized as one of the types of Business Corporations, the IRS did not create a new tax classification just for the LLC. LLCs were allowed to choose from the current tax classifications.
Choosing a Classification for Your LLC
In terms of owners’ protection against liability, perpetual existence, & savings in Taxation, both LLCs (Limited Liability Companies) & Corporations are very much alike. However, with regard to formalities, Taxation, & capital, LLCs & Corporations differ in New York.
Liabilities
Both LLCs and Corporations provide liability protection to their owners. The LLC provides protection against inside liability (towards the employee) & outside liability (towards the creditor). The Corporation usually provides only the inside liability.
Tax Classification Flexibility
For taxation purposes, an LLC has a choice of being treated as a sole proprietorship, Partnership, C-corporation, or S-corporation. A corporation can choose to be treated only as a C or S Corporation.
Taxation
As mentioned earlier, the LLC can choose to be treated as a corporation; the Corporation does not have the option of being treated as an LLC. A New York LLC is subject to Franchise tax, Federal Income Tax, Sales & Use Taxes & State Employment Taxes (for LLCs that have employees)
A regular corporation or a C-Corporation is subject to corporate tax, which can be filed through Form 1120 every year. The shareholders have to pay the income tax only when they receive dividends from the Corporation. These dividends are taxed twice at the corporate level (on a corporate form)& at the shareholder level (on shareholder form).
An S-Corporation in an LLC is not subject to corporate taxes. But the shareholders are subjected to Taxation – even if they do not receive any dividends. A member of a New York S-corporation has to pay Federal Self-Employment Tax only on his salary; any other profits that he makes through the LLC are not subject to the 15.3% Self-Employment Tax.
Classification of LLC Taxes – At a Glance
| Points of Difference | LLC | S- Corporation | C-Corporation | Sole Proprietorship |
| Taxation | As an LLC, by default, there is no tax levied at the entity level. The members’ income or even the loss is passed through to members or owners. | Similar to LLC, no tax is levied on an S-Corporation at the entity level. The members’ income or even the loss is passed through to the members or owners. | The C-Corporation is often taxed at the entity level. The Dividends are taxed at the shareholders’ level. | The sole proprietorship as an entity is not taxable. The Sole Proprietor pays taxes as an Individual. |
| Double Taxation | The LLC does not have Double Taxation | There is no Double Taxation in S-Corporation | There is Double Taxation in C-Corporations, only when the Shareholders earn in the form of dividends. | No Double Taxation in a sole proprietorship. |
| Self-Employment Tax | The net income of the members or owners is subject to self-employment tax. | The salaries of the shareholder are subject to self-employment tax, but any other profits that the shareholder makes are not subject to the employment tax. | The C-Corporation is subject to self-employment tax. | The sole proprietorship is subject to self-employment tax |
| Pass-Through Income/Loss | An LLC is often referred to as a Pass-through entity because its income passes through/ passes to its members. | Yes, An S Corporation is a Pass-through Entity. | No, A C-Corporation is not a Pass-through Entity. | Yes, a sole proprietorship is a Pass-through Entity. |
FAQ
C-Corporation. It taxes the dividends of the shareholders at the corporate level as well as at the individual level.
An LLC is often referred to as a pass-through entity because the income or the assets pass through the members or owners of the LLC.
The LLCs have two default classifications. It can be termed as a single-member LLC or a multi-member LLC.
When choosing a different classification for taxation, it is essential to understand the liabilities & taxes applicable in that classification.
How Do LLCs Pay Taxes in New York
One of the main advantages of LLCs is that they are generally not subject to federal income tax. Instead, the profits and losses of the business “pass through” to the individual owners, who report them on their personal tax returns. This pass-through taxation is one of the key benefits of forming an LLC, as it allows for the avoidance of double taxation that can occur with corporations.
In New York, LLCs are also subject to state-level taxes. The state imposes a filing fee and requires LLCs to file an annual report with the Department of State. Additionally, LLCs may be subject to a state-level LLC fee, which is based on the income of the business. This fee can vary depending on the business’s annual income, so it’s crucial for owners to understand their tax obligations and plan accordingly.
Another tax consideration for LLCs in New York is the sales tax. If the LLC sells goods or services in the state, it must collect and remit sales tax to the Department of Taxation and Finance. Failure to do so can result in penalties and interest, so it’s essential for LLC owners to keep accurate records of sales and sales tax collected.
Additionally, LLCs in New York may be subject to other taxes, such as property tax or payroll taxes. It’s important for owners to consult with a tax professional to ensure that they are meeting all of their tax obligations and taking advantage of any available deductions or credits.
In conclusion, while the tax treatment of LLCs in New York can be complex, the flexibility and tax benefits they offer make them an attractive option for small business owners. By understanding their tax obligations and working with a qualified tax professional, LLC owners can ensure that they are compliant with state tax laws and maximize their tax savings.
In Conclusion
Every Tax classification has its own set of benefits & restrictions. Every state will have different taxation rules for each of the categories of business corporations. Depending on the objective of formation of the business entity (Eg, to avoid dual Taxation- one can choose S Corporation, for more flexibility, one can choose the LLC format). It is essential to understand the taxing structure of each country & each Classification to decide how you wish to treat your LLC.